Analysis of Recent Trends in Case Court Cases Regarding Inventive Step

Authors： Junko Tsuji
Co-authored; 2017 Patent Committee, Subcommittee 2, Inventive Step Study Team
Magazine/Book：Patent Vol. 72, No. 2, pp. 52-62
Publisher：Japan Patent Attorneys Association
Practice： Intellectual Property Dispute Resolution Intellectual Property Transactions Intellectual Property Dispute Resolution
Date of publication： May 10, 2019

Other publications by Junko Tsuji

2026.05.10
A Multifaceted Examination of Legal Practice Related to Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries; Technology and Intellectual Property Related to Trees and Insects
2026.01.30
(Q67) Principle of Territoriality
2025.12.10
Examples of Intellectual Property and Business Strategies for Agricultural and Environmental Biotech Startups
2025.01.20
Article 10 (Orders to Protect Confidentiality); Article 11 (Rescission of Protective Orders)
2025.01.10
Decision of the Court of First Instance of the Unified Patent Court Central Division (Section Munich)on July 16 2024 — A Central Attack on a Patent for an Antibody Drug Characterized by Means
2022.05.30
Chapter 2: Data Transaction Contracts, II. Data Creation Contracts
2020.09.10
Analysis of Domestic Court Cases concerning Inventions Related to Computer Software (CS)
2020.08.13
Consideration on the Bill of the Act Partially Amending the Plant Variety Protection and Seed Act — For the Protection of New Varieties of Plants
2019.12.10
Appropriate Protection of AI and IoT-Related Inventions
2019.09.14
Q21: Protection through Patents in Agriculture, Forestry, Fisheries, and Food Industries
2019.07.10
A Case in Which Production, Transfer, etc. of Software was Found to Constitute Indirect Infringement of an Invention of a Device (Article 101, Item (ii) of the Patent Act)
2019.05.30
Q13: Inventiveness (4) — Methods of Business; Q42: Application (2) — Supporting Requirements, etc.; and Q76: Terms of Claims

MORE

Other publications about Intellectual Property Dispute Resolution

2026.01.30
(Q67) Principle of Territoriality
2025.01.20
Article 10 (Orders to Protect Confidentiality); Article 11 (Rescission of Protective Orders)
2025.01.10
Decision of the Court of First Instance of the Unified Patent Court Central Division (Section Munich)on July 16 2024 — A Central Attack on a Patent for an Antibody Drug Characterized by Means
2020.09.10
Analysis of Domestic Court Cases concerning Inventions Related to Computer Software (CS)
2020.08.13
Consideration on the Bill of the Act Partially Amending the Plant Variety Protection and Seed Act — For the Protection of New Varieties of Plants
2019.07.10
A Case in Which Production, Transfer, etc. of Software was Found to Constitute Indirect Infringement of an Invention of a Device (Article 101, Item (ii) of the Patent Act)
2019.05.30
Q13: Inventiveness (4) — Methods of Business; Q42: Application (2) — Supporting Requirements, etc.; and Q76: Terms of Claims
2019.05.10
Analysis of Recent Trends in Case Court Cases Regarding Inventive Step

MORE

Other publications about Intellectual Property Transactions

2026.05.10
A Multifaceted Examination of Legal Practice Related to Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries; Technology and Intellectual Property Related to Trees and Insects
2026.04.24
Lexology Panoramic - Designs 2026 - Japan Chapter
2026.01.30
(Q67) Principle of Territoriality
2025.12.10
Examples of Intellectual Property and Business Strategies for Agricultural and Environmental Biotech Startups
2025.09.26
Patent Utilization Strategies: Patent Funds and Key Contractual Considerations
2025.07.01
Strategies for Patent Utilization – Overview of Patent Funds and Points in Concluding Contracts -
2025.01.10
Decision of the Court of First Instance of the Unified Patent Court Central Division (Section Munich)on July 16 2024 — A Central Attack on a Patent for an Antibody Drug Characterized by Means
2024.09.27
Some Legal Issues Concerning the Use of Copyrighted Works in the Development and Learning Phases of Generative AI
2024.05.01
Legal Issues Related to Generative AI
2024.04.20
Judgment in Which the Court Determined Whether or Not the Relevant Act Constitutes an Indirect Infringement by a Non-Exclusive Article (Item 2, Article 101 of the Patent Act) Pertaining to Invention of a Product- Requirements for Indirect Infringement by Non-Exclusive Article -
2024.04.10
Foreign Filling Restrictions of Major Countries －Mechanisms to Restrict Foreign Filing of Sensitive Inventions－
2023.11.20
Inventions Made Across Boarders and the Attachment Foreign Filling Restrictions: Conflicts in the Restrictions and How They Are Handled
2023.08.24
Thematic-based: Legal Practice in the Healthcare Business
2023.05.20
Japan M&A - Key Intellectual Property Issues in M&A Transactions -
2023.04.03
Avatarization of Celebrities and Contractual Practices in the Metaverse
2023.02.28
National Comparison Tables - Japan part
2022.12.16
JAPAN: An Introduction to Intellectual Property: Bengoshi
2022.10.03
Protection of Image Designs and Spatial Designs - Status and Practical Response after the 2019 Amendment to the Design Law
2022.07.15
Points to Note Before Entering into a Joint Research Contract with a Foreign AI Venture
2022.07.15
The Intellectual Property and Antitrust Review 7th edition Japan Part
2022.05.30
Chapter 2: Data Transaction Contracts, II. Data Creation Contracts
2022.05.18
Japan M&A - Key Intellectual Property Issues in M&A Transactions -
2022.03.11
A study of the secret patent systems of various countries, and the introduction of the same system in Japan (No.2)(end)
2022.03.01
Summary of Countermeasures for Counterfeit Products in the US
2022.02.17
NFT Mechanism and Legal Issues of NFT Transactions
2022.02.14
A study of the secret patent systems of various countries, and the introduction of the same system in Japan (No.1)
2022.02.04
A Case in Which the Applicability of Article 3, Paragraph 1, Item 3 of the Trademark Act was Disputed with Respect to the Trademark “VEGAS” (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2022 February Issue))
2022.01.12
Subject Matter of License and “Implied License” under Patent License Agreements Written in English
2021.12.23
Latest Developments in the Japanese Patent Practice
2021.12.01
A Detailed Explanation of Economic Partnership Agreements
2021.10.01
Obligation to Conclude Multilateral Treaties in the Field of Intellectual Property through FTA/EPA - Efforts to Strengthen Protection of Rights and to Achieve International Harmonization of Systems -
2021.08.05
A Case in Which a Court Admission Rendered in the First Trial was Overturned upon Considering Issues of Conventional Technology and Revising Judgment Based on the Fulfillment Theory (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2021 August Issue))
2021.07.15
The Intellectual Property and Antitrust Review 6th edition Japan Part
2021.05.07
A Case in Which the Japan Patent Office and the Court Reached Different Decisions Regarding Similarity in the Inventive Step of Two Inventions (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2021 May Issue))
2021.05.01
Japan M&A - Key Intellectual Property Issues in M&A Transactions -
2021.03.31
Protection of Geographical Indications under the TPP and Japan-EU Economic Partnership Agreement (EPA)
2021.03.05
A Case Involving a Dispute Over Similarity of Trademarks and Other Matters Related to Services Supporting Job Seeking Activities by Currently Unemployed Recent Graduates with Work Experience (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2021 March Issue))
2021.01.26
Intellectual Property Newsletter (Digest version) (2021 Winter Issue) Key Points in Reading Case Reports
2020.12.21
2021 Book Guide for Legal Affairs "Updates to Common Business Sense in Response to Changes in the Social Environment" -Business Law Journal, February 2021 Issue
2020.09.10
Analysis of Domestic Court Cases concerning Inventions Related to Computer Software (CS)
2020.08.13
Consideration on the Bill of the Act Partially Amending the Plant Variety Protection and Seed Act — For the Protection of New Varieties of Plants
2020.07.31
How to Proceed with Joint Research and Development and Legal Points to Note therein（Chapter 4: Section 1 "Points on Patent License Agreement and Way of thinking on Provisions"）
2020.07.01
The Intellectual Property and Antitrust Review 5th edition Japan Part
2019.12.10
Appropriate Protection of AI and IoT-Related Inventions
2019.09.14
Q21: Protection through Patents in Agriculture, Forestry, Fisheries, and Food Industries
2019.07.10
A Case in Which Production, Transfer, etc. of Software was Found to Constitute Indirect Infringement of an Invention of a Device (Article 101, Item (ii) of the Patent Act)
2019.05.30
Q13: Inventiveness (4) — Methods of Business; Q42: Application (2) — Supporting Requirements, etc.; and Q76: Terms of Claims
2019.05.10
Analysis of Recent Trends in Case Court Cases Regarding Inventive Step
2019.01.01
Business and IP commitments in Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs)
2018.09.06
Points on Provisions of Patent License Agreement - Based on Revision of Civil Code -
2018.08.28
The Act on Special Measures for Productivity Improvement (Part 2) - Outline of the System to Facilitate Data Sharing and Collaboration
2018.08.10
The Act on Special Measures for Productivity Improvement (Part 1) - What does the “Regulatory Sandbox” mean?
2018.03.21
The Compass for Intellectual Property Law - The Supreme Court Ruled on a Re-defense based on a Correction of Claims against a Patent Invalidity Defense in a Patent Infringement Case
2018.03.01
IP Laws of the Philippines
2018.02.19
Q&A on the Actual Practice of Employee Inventions (Keiso’s Law and Practice Series)(co-author)
2017.05.01
JAPAN Section/Protection and Disclosure of Trade Secrets and Know-How
2015.03.01
Handbook on Joint Research and Development Agreement
2015.02.01
Reading of U.S. Supreme Court Cases: Commentary on Intellectual Property and Business Cases in the 21st Century
2010.09.01
Intellectual Property Commitments in Japan's Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs)
2010.01.01
Negotiations regarding Intellectual Property in Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs), [1] - [9]
2007.05.01
Commentary on FTA/EPA Negotiations

MORE

Other publications about Intellectual Property Dispute Resolution

2026.04.24
Lexology Panoramic - Designs 2026 - Japan Chapter
2026.04.20
JP-DRP Precedent Review Report (2026 Edition)
2026.01.30
(Q67) Principle of Territoriality
2025.07.29
Pantech v Google: Tokyo District Court grants first injunction for SEP infringement（Co-authored）
2025.01.20
Article 10 (Orders to Protect Confidentiality); Article 11 (Rescission of Protective Orders)
2025.01.10
Decision of the Court of First Instance of the Unified Patent Court Central Division (Section Munich)on July 16 2024 — A Central Attack on a Patent for an Antibody Drug Characterized by Means
2024.05.01
Legal Issues Related to Generative AI
2024.04.20
Judgment in Which the Court Determined Whether or Not the Relevant Act Constitutes an Indirect Infringement by a Non-Exclusive Article (Item 2, Article 101 of the Patent Act) Pertaining to Invention of a Product- Requirements for Indirect Infringement by Non-Exclusive Article -
2023.08.24
Thematic-based: Legal Practice in the Healthcare Business
2023.02.28
National Comparison Tables - Japan part
2022.03.01
Summary of Countermeasures for Counterfeit Products in the US
2022.02.04
A Case in Which the Applicability of Article 3, Paragraph 1, Item 3 of the Trademark Act was Disputed with Respect to the Trademark “VEGAS” (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2022 February Issue))
2021.12.01
A Detailed Explanation of Economic Partnership Agreements
2021.08.05
A Case in Which a Court Admission Rendered in the First Trial was Overturned upon Considering Issues of Conventional Technology and Revising Judgment Based on the Fulfillment Theory (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2021 August Issue))
2021.05.07
A Case in Which the Japan Patent Office and the Court Reached Different Decisions Regarding Similarity in the Inventive Step of Two Inventions (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2021 May Issue))
2021.04.01
Patent Enforcement Practices Before, During and After Patent Litigation Proceedings in Japan – A Comparative Analysis with Germany and the United States –
2021.03.05
A Case Involving a Dispute Over Similarity of Trademarks and Other Matters Related to Services Supporting Job Seeking Activities by Currently Unemployed Recent Graduates with Work Experience (Intellectual Property Newsletter (2021 March Issue))
2021.01.26
Intellectual Property Newsletter (Digest version) (2021 Winter Issue) Key Points in Reading Case Reports
2021.01.01
The Ways of Limiting Injunctive Relief in Patent Infringement Litigation and their Effects – Current Japanese Practices and Suggestions for their Future Improvements, based on the Recent Trends in Germany and the United States –
2020.09.10
Analysis of Domestic Court Cases concerning Inventions Related to Computer Software (CS)
2020.08.13
Consideration on the Bill of the Act Partially Amending the Plant Variety Protection and Seed Act — For the Protection of New Varieties of Plants
2019.07.10
A Case in Which Production, Transfer, etc. of Software was Found to Constitute Indirect Infringement of an Invention of a Device (Article 101, Item (ii) of the Patent Act)
2019.05.30
Q13: Inventiveness (4) — Methods of Business; Q42: Application (2) — Supporting Requirements, etc.; and Q76: Terms of Claims
2019.05.10
Analysis of Recent Trends in Case Court Cases Regarding Inventive Step
2019.01.01
Business and IP commitments in Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs)
2018.03.21
The Compass for Intellectual Property Law - The Supreme Court Ruled on a Re-defense based on a Correction of Claims against a Patent Invalidity Defense in a Patent Infringement Case
2018.03.01
IP Laws of the Philippines
2018.02.19
Q&A on the Actual Practice of Employee Inventions (Keiso’s Law and Practice Series)(co-author)
2015.02.01
Reading of U.S. Supreme Court Cases: Commentary on Intellectual Property and Business Cases in the 21st Century
2007.05.01
Commentary on FTA/EPA Negotiations
2006.04.01
Guide to International Legal Practice (1) to (11)

MORE

Contact us

ページTOPへ